If the witness who had never taken a bubble before and the effect of the dash cam he brought to Fu Daidi and others were shocking, the witness who appeared later was the last straw to crush Fu Daidi and others.
Old lady Xu, Fu Daidi's old neighbor and sister, is also the old mother of the middle-aged white fat man who testified for her this time. The other party actually appeared in the court as Yan Chu's witness.
After learning the identity of the other party, not only the people in the audience, but also the judge couldn't help but be surprised.
The son and mother testify to the plaintiff and the defendant respectively. In this way, one of them is perjury?
"On that day, my son came back with his newly bought car. Zhang Baozhu was also at home. He rubbed my son to let him have a good time in the driver's seat. At that time, it was agreed that he would only have a good time in the alley. Who knows, when he drove outside the yard of the Zhang family, Fu Daidi came down from the upstairs. She was standing in the dead corner of her sight and was hit by the car. Although the speed was slow, she was also very slow Hurt a bone. "
Old lady Xu is not young, but her thinking is still clear.
These days, she was tortured by nightmares. The old lady was originally a superstitious person. She had a bad heart. In her dream, she dreamed that she would go down the oil pot and go to the knife mountain when she committed this great sin. The pain that tore her heart and lungs is still vivid. In addition, she went to the temple to pray incense not long ago and wanted to add some sesame oil money to make atonement for herself and her son and come out of the temple, The words of the very effective master made her make up her mind.
Now she and her son have great sins. They must wash away their sins before they die. This is why she has been struggling for a long time and finally stood up at the last moment.
"Because Zhang Baozhu was flustered at that time and didn't want to bear the responsibility, he came up with this move and asked old lady Fu to touch porcelain in the road section just built not far from the village in the city and with few driving vehicles. My son was kind, so he made perjury for them."
Mrs. Xu's words have been beautified. In fact, her son can easily promise to help Fu Daidi do perjury, just to get rid of his responsibility.
The situation of borrowing his car is different from that of Yan Chu. Zhang Baozhu has no driver's license. In this case, he lent his car to Zhang Baozhu, and in the event of an accident, he is also the person responsible for the accident and needs to bear compensation.
At that time, Zhang Baozhu didn't know this. Just seeing that he hurt my mother, he was scared out of control. Isn't this panic a bad idea.
In fact, after hearing the case of Lin Fushou and others, he had regretted that if he had bitten Mrs. Xu's son to death, he would have no trouble at all.
"Defendant witness, do you have evidence to prove your testimony?"
Lawyer Jiang endured the heat in his heart and exercised his legitimate rights in law.
"Yes, yes, yes."
Old lady Xu nodded. She came to atone for her sins. What if the Bodhisattva thought she didn't do good, and then let her go to hell on the 18th floor.
"My son's car was scratched when he hit Fu Daidi. For fear of causing trouble, he still parked in the garage and didn't send it for repair. Aren't you police very capable? Just compare the scratched wall outside Zhang's building."
Mrs. Xu said without hesitation. She also heard these words from Yan Chu's lawyer, Learn and use flexibly: "Zhang Baozhu is not a thing before. I don't know where I heard what car is mainly responsible for the trouble caused by the borrower. In this case, I blackmailed my son 20000 yuan. That money is still my pension money. I took it from my social security account and called Zhang Baozhu's card."
Lawyer Jiang glared at Zhang Baozhu, who was guilty. He felt powerless. He thought he had done everything possible in this case and couldn't bear to have a pig teammate who had been holding him back.
In fact, when the two witnesses and their exhibits appeared, everything was clear. Those who have eyes and can argue between right and wrong should see clearly.
Usually, such cases will not be closed on the spot. They still have a period of time to supplement evidence and wait for the next hearing.
However, when the court withdrew, everyone had a final conclusion about the outcome of the case.
Because of the heat of this case, today's audience is full. As soon as the court trial is over, the scenes in the court appear on the Internet in every detail. I don't know which brave person secretly photographed the court trial video and uploaded it to the largest video website. It has been clicked by tens of millions overnight.
How much I sympathized with Fu Daidi's kind old lady and how much I loved Zhang Baozhu's filial son. Now the netizen's face hurts.
This case is not just that ordinary elderly people are falsely accused. From beginning to end, this is a premeditated and planned "porcelain touch", which is completely abusing today's society, leaving only a few conscience.
Maybe it's because they used to scold too hard. Now netizens can't even say an apology. They can only express their attitude in silence.
******
"Sorry."
The middle-aged man who had just testified for Yan Chu in court tangled for a long time, walked up to Yan Chu and said to him.
Before, he was not going to go through this muddy water. He was an ordinary company employee. He and his wife carefully cultivated a daughter, carrying decades of housing and car loans. Occasionally, he could not make ends meet. He could not be filial to the elderly, but also needed subsidies from the elderly.
In this case, any twists and turns can't be borne by men.
He is afraid of provoking people like Zhang Baozhu and losing his job. He is also afraid of hurting his daughter because of his so-called sense of justice. After all, you can't guarantee what means a person with no bottom line will use.
If it hadn't been for the anonymous email he received in his mailbox a few days ago and the 100000 yuan that somehow appeared at his door, he wouldn't have come to be this witness.
You can call him selfish, but in today's society, they prefer to call themselves reason.
The man didn't know how the person who sent the e-mail to him knew that there would be a tachograph picture of old lady Fu lying on the ground. There was nothing * * in today's society. He panicked for a while and put it down.
What impressed him was the 100000 yuan. His daughter was about to go to junior high school. A better public school could not be ranked, and the tuition fees of private schools were high. With the 100000 yuan, at least he could guarantee that the expenses of his family would not be so tight in the next three years. Therefore, even if he knew that there was a risk of sinners, he still came.
I just don't know why, looking at Yan Chu's eyes on the witness stand, he actually felt inexplicable shame, especially after learning that the porcelain touch was the result of the careful planning of the Zhang family.
He couldn't help thinking about how he would feel as a parent if it was his daughter.
I can't help thinking, as a child's father, if he doesn't stand up today, if he doesn't have the 100000 yuan, a young man who has done good deeds but has been falsely accused will be held accountable. Will this sense of guilt haunt his life? Does he really deserve to be a child's father? What qualifications does he have to educate his daughter.
Life in the world, in addition to living, there should always be some other pursuit, but they are numb.
"I'll pay you back the money."
The 100000 yuan was either given by Yan Chu or helped by the people around him. The man felt that he was not qualified to accept the 100000 yuan.
After saying this, most of his original guilt disappeared, and he felt free of himself.
*****
After Fu Daidi's case came to an end temporarily, the case of Xu Shufen and others was heard immediately.
In this case, Yan Chu was the plaintiff, suing Xu Shufen and others for extortion, slander, insult and other charges.
In court, Xu Shufen bit Du Juan and others to death. They knew that her son Yan Tian had a history of drunk driving, so as to prove Yan Chu's fault in borrowing the car. If this is true, the various charges filed by Yan Chu will not be established.
Correspondingly, Yan Chu took out several recordings and other auxiliary evidence.
The first recording was recorded on the day of Yan Tian's car accident. The background sound was a little noisy. I heard Xu Shufen calling her son during the square dance.
On the phone, Xu Shufen had a sharp voice and asked her son if he had drunk and drove again. On the way, because the radio sound of square dance was a little loud, some conversations were not clear. At the end of the recording, Xu Shufen ended with a loud "son".
Based on the recording time and the autopsy report of Yan Tian and others, it is estimated that Yan Tian was driving after drinking and talking to Xu Shufen during driving, resulting in a double violation.
As the last person to talk to Yan Tian after the crime, Xu Shufen should know this, but she didn't say anything.
The second recording is a telephone recording between Du Juan and Xu Shufen.
When Yan Chu came back from a business trip, she called Xu Shufen on time. At that time, Xu Shufen thought that Du Juan was a new car in love with her family and was stingy and didn't want to lend her son a car. Therefore, in the phone, she assured Du Juan that her son would drive carefully and never drink, He promised to return his family's car safely. This recording also confirmed the statement that Yan Yinsheng and his family did not know that Yan Tian had a history of drunk driving.
In court, as long as the recording is not obtained by eavesdropping, coercion and other means, it can be used as evidence. However, due to the limitations of the recording itself, it is difficult to make it a complete evidence, and other auxiliary proofs are often required.
Therefore, the first recording was accompanied by a video, which was shot in the square that day. In the video, scenes of Xu Shufen's location were clearly photographed. The video picture was aimed at her front, which can rely on her mouth shape in the video to prove the authenticity of the recording.
Of course, the recording was also obtained legally. At that time, a band was going to record its own tracks there and record the call between Xu Shufen and her son. It was a pure coincidence.
In addition, Lin Fushou and others have made a big fuss about the bad acts of the Yan Family and the Yan Chu company, as well as their family videos threatening Yan Chu to pay huge compensation, which are all presented as evidence.
Seeing the thick pile of evidence, Lin Fushou and others couldn't help but be frightened. Where did the other party find so many evidence? Then forget the evidence. Earlier, it was said that the last phone call between Xu Shufen and her son was so coincidental. Someone took a video and someone recorded it. It was so coincidental that Yan Chu found them.
Of course, no one thought it was planned by Yan Chu in advance. He was not a prophet. He also knew that his cousin would have a car accident that night. Did he know that his aunt would push him out later in order to get rid of his relationship?
Isn't this a daydream?
Therefore, all the people present except Xu Shufen and others sighed in their hearts. Is this the so-called justice?
*****
In addition to the two most difficult cases, other trivial Internet libel cases and insult cases are only a small matter for those lawyers. At most, it takes some time. Only their assistants are enough to complete these cases.
This vigorous network farce, from the beginning to the complete end, has a history of four months. In addition to many people involved, it is also inseparable from today's complex judicial procedures.
Without exception, Yan Chu won every case.
Fu Daidi was sentenced to attempted extortion and only needed administrative punishment. Because she was 70 years old, she was exempted from public security administrative punishment. Zhang Baozhu was sentenced to two months' imprisonment, a fine of 5000 yuan, and a compensation of 20000 yuan for Yan Chu's spiritual loss.
The worst is that old lady Xu's son was sentenced to three months for perjury, which is higher than the two culprits Fu Daidi and Zhang Baozhu.
As for Xu Shufen and others, the charges are lighter than those of Zhang Baozhu and others. As lawyer Jiang said before, they did not receive money for extortion. At most, they were an attempted extortion. This is not a high legal penalty, except that leaders such as Xu Shufen and Lin Fushou were sentenced to six months' imprisonment and fined, Other accomplices were sentenced to two months and one month respectively, and even those smart families called the old man at home when they made trouble. Now, like Fu Daidi, they were exempted from any punishment.
It seems that the law has lightened their punishment. In fact, this is the effect Yan Chu wants. At least in the network public opinion, as he expected, it exploded.
Originally, this was a case that attracted a lot of attention, not to mention the netizens who fell into the wave of internet war at that time. After half a year of fermentation, a case was pronounced from time to time. The news about Yan Chu never left the public's sight. In the end, as long as they did not deviate from the society, they knew such a case, including many law majors, They all took this case as a case and were mentioned in class.
How many people misunderstood Yan Chu on the Internet at the beginning, and now how many people feel guilty. Especially after the truth came out, netizens who realized that they had been cheated by Fu Daidi and others wanted to score a minute and let them explode in situ.
They have been looking forward to the trial for so long just to see the outcome of those people. The result is good. Even if the light punishment has passed, some of them can't even compare with those sentences for online slander.
You know, thousands of online libel cases involved other cases because of the defendant's identity as a professional water army. The highest sentencing reached the sentencing limit stipulated in this kind of penalty and was sentenced to three years.
The expectation is as big as the disappointment. Originally, in their view, Fu Daidi and others should be punished more severely, so as to warn those who have the same ideas as them.
The current results obviously did not meet everyone's expectations.
However, the law is so stipulated. It is absolutely not a simple matter of public opinion to change a country's legislative rules.
*****
The case is over, but his influence is far more than that.
Yan Chu invested nearly 20 million in this case, just because he has a good fortune in stocks. Now he has more than that. He took out 10 million in his name to help those good people who were falsely accused of doing good but unable to refute. Similarly, this money is also used to help ordinary people who suffer from campus violence and online violence, As long as they are willing, they can always get assistance to defend their rights.
Although the law may not give you the best protection and can't let the bad guys get the punishment they deserve, at least this is an attitude. Yan Chu wants to tell everyone that it's right to do good deeds and that if they are infringed, they should also have the courage to resist.
Perhaps the current law is not perfect, and the improvement of justice also needs a long cycle, but who knows whether their current efforts will accelerate this process.
At first, no one dared to stand up until a little girl appeared at the charity foundation established by Yan Chu with her father's portrait.
She came here secretly by herself. Her father was blackmailed by the old man he helped because he did good deeds. Because he could not bear the harassment of the old man's relatives, he was also unwilling to drag down his family. With endless grievances, he jumped into the river and killed himself.
Those who forced her father to die, however, did not have the slightest sense of guilt. They still forced those who were still alive to ask for huge compensation.
The girl didn't believe that her father would be the villain who dared to do it in the mouth of the villains who smashed their family. She didn't want her father to die innocent. Even if there was only a little hope, she still skipped class and came quietly.
This case is the first case accepted by the foundation. Because of the long time, it is very difficult to obtain evidence, but the result is still good. They finally found a tourist who witnessed the facts at the beginning. The other party doesn't know what happened later. They just think this is an episode on the way of travel and regret that they killed a human life because of their carelessness at the beginning.
Because of the appearance of the other party, more and more vicious onlookers who had been afraid of the family came forward.
The man who died in vain finally got justice late.
Gradually, more and more people began to trust the sudden emergence of the foundation, because more and more cases were published on the foundation's website. Looking at the tragic end of those who did good deeds, once as a bystander and a member of self-protection, they couldn't help but start to reflect on whether their original behavior was correct.
Admittedly, the rehabilitation of every case can not be successful, and the judgment of the law on the wicked is often unsatisfactory.
But everyone has seen a bright future. I believe that in the near future, the law will hear their voice and become more and more perfect, so that the wicked dare not do evil and the good are safe.
*****
Fu Daidi lost the lawsuit. Although she didn't go to jail because of her age, her end was no better.
Because Zhang Baozhu was sentenced, her daughter-in-law complained about her and drove her out of the house. Several other children were ashamed of her because of her stinky Street reputation. If she hadn't gone to court, I'm afraid she wouldn't even give her the lowest alimony.
Because there was not enough medical expenses, Fu Daidi's injured leg was not well maintained. In her old age, the pain of her legs and feet accompanied her for the rest of her life.
Yan Chu founded the foundation and was respected by many people in China. On the contrary, she, who tried to frame him, was despised by many people.
If you want to pick up garbage, be excluded, and beg, you only have to show your face. All you have to wait for is spittle and Stone mud on the ground.
Fu Daidi thought that the outcome of that dream was already a nightmare. Unexpectedly, the reality she really experienced was more frightening than a nightmare.
Later, Fu Daidi endured the pain of her legs and feet and closed her eyes. When she died, she asked herself, was she wrong?
In addition to Fu Daidi, the rest of the Zhang family also had a hard time. They all participated in the original things. In addition to hiding in the gully, as long as they walked on the road, someone could recognize them. Their career was frustrated and they were despised in their life. The last development of the Zhang family's brothers and sisters was flat, which dragged down their children.
I don't know whether they regret their choice in every painful night.
*****
When Xu Shufen was in prison, Yan Jinsheng proposed to divorce her, because Xu Shufen participated in many of these things from beginning to end, and he was almost an invisible person, but how could Xu Shufen, who had only the last straw, let him go? Even if the court finally sentenced Yan Jinsheng and Xu Shufen to a forced divorce, he saw Yan Jinsheng remarried after he came out of prison, What Xu Shufen did was to insert into the newlyweds with an arrogant attitude.
Of course, it's not over. Yan Chu and others don't have enough money. Not only that, Lin Fushou and others are also carrying high compensation. Therefore, they turn their eyes to Xu Shufen and Yan Jinsheng. It was Yan Tian who drank and drove at the beginning, and the old house of the Yan family where the couple now live was recorded in the name of their grandson Yan Tian when their ancestors died at the beginning.
Originally it was to save a round of inheritance tax, but now it has become the most powerful weapon for Lin Fushou and others to obtain compensation.
As the fault Party of the car accident, the house under Yan Tian's name should naturally be distributed to the families of the other three victims as compensation.
Several families were in a frenzy. Because of the previous case, all of them lost their jobs and their future. They dared to walk on the road only after camouflage.
It is estimated that one day when Yan Chu is no longer active in the public eye, their once bedbugs will be forgotten and see the light again. Therefore, the only thing they can grasp is the old and small set of Yan Jinsheng's family.
Finally, Lin Fushou and others certainly got what they wanted, but this also angered Xu Shufen. After she was released from prison, that family was her only hope, a more reliable hope than Yan Jinsheng.
Lin Fushou, who ruined all this, naturally became a thorn in her eye.
I don't know where she bought some bottles of sulfuric acid, rushed to the Lin family and poured all the sulfuric acid on each other. Then she ran away in the exclamation of Lin Fushou's little wife, and took the remaining sulfuric acid to find Yan Chu, whom she hated most. But this time she was not so lucky. She was caught before she started.
This time, she was not so lucky and was sentenced to ten years in prison.
As for lawyer Jiang, who has always been interspersed in these two cases, his lawyer's license was revoked because he incited and abetted the parties to solve disputes by illegal means such as disturbing public order and endangering public security. At the same time, the online water army under Yan Chu's microblog was also proved to be hired by him, and published statements endangering national security, maliciously slandering others Speech that seriously disrupts the order of the court can also be revoked the lawyer's license.
Because of these acts, he was investigated for legal responsibility and sentenced to two years' imprisonment.
The means of making a living were gone, and his reputation was completely rotten. After he was released from prison, lawyer Jiang disappeared into the public's sight. No one knew where he had gone and what he was doing.
*****
For more than 50 years, the foundation established by Yan Chu has become bigger and bigger. The people of China jokingly call it the good man fund.
This title comes from Yan Chu's post court interview on the case of helping the elderly, which affected his whole life. At that time, the reporter asked him if he would help the elderly if he fell to the ground in the future.
Yan Chu said: Yes
The reporter asked him: why
Yan Chu replied: probably because my parents taught me to be a good man.
This answer seemed controversial at that time, because he sued too many people at one time. Some of those people were really just men and women who were bored and just cursed online to show their sense of existence. The criminal proceedings brought by the other party obviously had a fatal impact on the future of those people.
Whether this is a good person or not, no one can give an accurate answer.
But over the next 50 years, Yan Chu proved this with his own practical actions.
His life has been devoted to promoting the improvement of the judicial system. His foundation has helped many people in need.
No matter how much criticism there is on the Internet, how many people think that his practice is just fishing for fame and reputation. In his life, he has been a good man and a good man who has helped countless good people.
On the day of his death, mourners crowded the whole lane outside the Yan Family's old house. Many innocent children heard about the old man from their parents.
It turned out that helping the elderly was a terrible thing more than 50 years ago; It turned out that it took so much courage to be a witness; Originally, once slandered and insulted, it is so cost-free on the Internet
They can't say that this change was brought about by the old man named Yan Chu, but he was there and played an indelible role.
He's a good man!