The perfect ending of "clannad" in * *, which lasted for one year, has brought people countless touching and beautiful memories《 However, no work can have only one voice. The more popular the work is, the more intense the controversy will be.

EVA is an obvious example. Even though it has been over for a long time, people are still discussing it tirelessly《 Clannad also ushered in this step. It can be said that these controversial voices are just a kind of recognition of clannad - real gold is not afraid of fire, and excellent works are never afraid of any criticism.

"Clannad is just a cancer of society. The plot of dog blood is intended to make people cry. Gu Hezhu and Okazaki, who are ill, get married just after graduation and don't wear a condom, which leads to unexpected pregnancy. This is the root of all tragedies. And Zhu is also a fool. He is so weak that he has to insist on having children. Even if he has children, why don't he go to the hospital? I never thought about what to do if there is massive bleeding? What about all kinds of emergencies? Can any doctor be better than the condition of the hospital? If that's the case, then the hospital has set up a special obstetrics and gynecology department, and it will close down directly. "

"Under such circumstances, Zhu's death can't be more normal - it's their own death, and it's a miracle that Xiaoxi can survive - a miracle created by the author himself. I think Xiaoxi can't survive if the porters didn't want Xiaoxi to survive. In this way, Okazaki would fall into despair and never get the chance to atone. To have a child at home is such a willful and childish request. It seems moving, but it seems ridiculous to me. It's irresponsible for yourself and your children. It's also irresponsible to parents and husbands. "

"I cheated my tears with Zhu. Made Bento, and then hit the next wave of tears to Xiao Xi's body. When his wife died, his father left his child behind! By the way, maybe it's easier to create conflicts. If Okazaki works hard to raise her, will the tears be so strong after that? Does Xiao Xi still have a chance to say, "the only place to cry is in the toilet and dad's arms"? Although the final conscience, but also too late, Xiao Xi completed his tear mission. After receiving the Bento, she can finally leave this bloody world. Xiaoxi's life experience is not pitiful. I think the most pitiful thing is that she has such a pair of sb parents. Living in that world is a kind of suffering. Death is a relief! "

"Okazaki's way of doing this is not as good as his father, who has been despised by him all the time. If he died here, maybe I still think it's a movie that can at least make me happy, but in the end, it's a special way of resurrection! Actually shameless hooligans to read files again, before there was a bit of people feel good place. I'm totally disgusted by this move. It's like swallowing a fly. "

"I'm looking at the mess of news‘ After 90's * * gave birth to a child, they were unwilling to raise it, but their grandparents sued them on their behalf. "," a young couple gave birth to a child unmarried and refused to raise it because they had no financial basis. "," a young girl got pregnant unmarried and didn't know who her father was. "," a baby's body appeared again in the Internet bar toilet, and her minor mother was arrested for murdering her child. ", However, none of them has grown up. Apart from saying "love", they have no ability at all. If they use their parents' money to soak up their girls, they are irresponsible when something goes wrong. "Clannad" is a rubbish, a cancer! "

A netizen named "Bu Dong" quoted a lot of social news and flattened "clannad" for nothing.

It was immediately besieged by fans of "clannad.".

The black-and-white masked Post said: "what rubbish is there in" clannad "besides the dog blood? Is it not natural for other couples to want to make a man because of their love? You don't get married and have children? Besides, after graduating from high school, both of them have a low degree. Okazaki can only sell coolies to make money. Later, when Okazaki had a chance to get a better job, he lost the chance because of his father. I hate my father more. At this time, Guhe played a key role in making father and son understand each other. Isn't it realistic here? In order to support his wife hard work, but because of low education, but can only sell coolie. Guhe didn't die simply because he had a baby. Originally, Guhe was very weak. It was said in the previous doctor's story that it might be dangerous to have a baby. Guhe also wanted to give birth to a son for Okazaki. Gu he's condition can't be found in the hospital. Going to the hospital is just a psychological comfort, which can't actually solve the problem. Moreover, the doctors all think that they can give birth at home, because the family environment has a good promoting effect on the mood of the puerpera. But because of Gu he's death, Okazaki gave up the responsibility of raising his children( The two high school students were very immature when they decided to be together, but after that, Okazaki grew up from a little kid who graduated from high school to a man who can take responsibility and pick up the responsibility of raising his daughter again.) Finally, he took his daughter on the journey to make the story come to the end. Okazaki also realized the difficulties of his father at that time. Besides Guangyu, stories rise and fall, which can move me and make me understand a lot. Would you like to tell me how the story should develop? "Altoria then said sarcastically, "you should be dropped out of high school when you fall in love. Then you have a little fight for three days and a big fight for five days. After you break up, you are asked by your father to interrupt the dog's leg, right. Those news are even more strange. Have you never seen such news without "clannad"? It was not long ago that someone counted that since "clannad" was broadcast, there has been a lot less such news than before. You try your best to dig out a few pieces of news to spray, but you don't look at the missing ones. Such a positive and positive impact is something that you, a guy full of dirty and dark thoughts, can never understand. "

In the face of the siege, not moving, not falling momentum.

"You say the couple love each other, get married and want to make a man? Love a fart, Zhu's health is very bad, Okazaki is not unknown, in this case, he did not pay attention to Zhu's body, but also want to have a child... This is the rebellious high school graduates, impulsive, physiological needs, unexpected pregnancy. Just don't understand love will happen the following tragedy

"Okazaki lost a good job because of his father - so what? This is not the only job in the world. Thousands of jobs are waiting for him. If you lose your job, you can look for it again. Or is it because he is too incompetent? Not all people in the world are born to do something. You can find it if you look for it. How many people have changed their profession after they set foot in the society and are learning and making progress in their work. As long as they are literate, there is nothing they can't do. Just see if he is willing to work hard. Okazaki's hard work makes him look down on those people who are really working hard. "

"Work is not stable, can't support, wife is not in good health, still anxious to have children? It shows the unique thinking of high school students. They don't even know contraception, and they don't think about what life will be like in the future. It's not that sperm on the brain leads to unexpected pregnancy, and it's obvious that the plot of brain disease. Zhu insisted on having children at home or having children at home, which shows the lack of education all the year round and the childish girl who takes having children as a child's play. Insisting on not going to the hospital is her own irresponsible and willful behavior towards her family, and she killed herself. Because of Zhu's death. Okazaki's heart is like ashes. He gives up the responsibility of raising his children. It's the crystallization of the two, but his heart is like ashes. The so-called "love" of these two people is too ridiculous and naive, and it's too scum to give up raising them for a time. "

"It's because of the super dog blood reading that such a mediocre life movie becomes rubbish. It's still a good campus animation until the first half of Okazaki and Zhu's love affair. In the second half of the movie, the porters specially add the setting that makes the protagonist extremely stupid and childish in order to create conflict and tear effect, Then let the mother and son die in this setting to win the audience's tears. There is no touching plot, full of rebellion, childishness and irresponsibility. Such scum protagonists should not be redeemed, or regret to commit suicide or die alone, to give the world enlightenment! "

Although the words are very fierce, they are clearly organized, which not only infuriates the fans, but also makes them unable to refute. It's really angry.

Some fans even suspect that it's Huang shaotian's product again, because the strong style of the sprayer really reminds people of Huang shaotian, the "bad" big sprayer.

So that Huang shaotian had to stand up in person and resolutely draw a clear line with this man to prove his innocence. After all, he is a famous person, and everyone knows him. If he is cheated by others' spray, which leads to something dangerous happening to him in the end, he will have to die unjustly.

As for the view of "clannad", as a romantic drama, he likes this work very much. The only thing he feels uncomfortable with is the great resurrection of the last reading, which immediately turns his moved tears into jokes. This is also the only flaw of "clannad" that some audiences think.

Cao Jun also joined in the debate: "I think" clannad "should be viewed from another angle, just as people can't be born with certain things, these things are learned, and people can't be mature at birth, and" clannad "describes the story from childish to mature through the life of various characters. At the beginning, they were really naive and very naive. That's right. But it's because of their naivety that people can reflect on themselves so deeply and make people mature with the protagonists in the story - how can we see a rainbow without wind and rain? "

"It's a failure to describe their style from the perspective of maturity at the beginning, because they were only two high school students at the beginning, and they didn't even experience the society. How can they be mature? Okazaki can't find a good job because he doesn't study well. What you see is a negative story, ridiculing and spitting at the protagonist, but what I see is a positive story. Isn't Okazaki's story a warning to us? If you don't study hard and try to enrich yourself, even if you meet a good girl like Zhu, you can't give a happy life to the people you love and get mature from Okazaki. I think this is what the master really wants to tell us. "

"And the last great resurrection of reading files, although it seems very disobedient and lowers the previous moving, I don't think clarnad is selling on moving. The final turning point is very blunt and abrupt, which makes people unable to laugh or cry, and returns to reality from the story. But when you think about it, isn't that saying that these fictional stories have a chance to come back, but in life? There is no chance to come back in real life! Cherish life, cherish happiness, cherish life"Clannad is life!"( Not finished, to be continued