A Mishap Gone Right (Fairy Tail)

A Mishap Gone Right (Fairy Tail)

A/N: A Mishap Gone Right was a commissioned one-shot originally written in September of 2018! Posting it now for people to enjoy.

Summary: In which Juvia acquires a potion that won't make Gray love her, but will instead simply make him more suggestible to her advances. Of course, things never go well for the poor besotted woman. In the end, the potion ends up where it shouldn't, and Natsu consumes his fair share. But he's not the only one who gets dosed...

Themes: Minor Brainwashing, Fucked Silly, Quasi-NTR

-x-X-x-

To say Juvia Lockser was merely excited would be a gross understatement. No, as the blue-haired young woman lay on her bed in the Fairy Tail's women's dormitory, surrounded by every piece of memorabilia from Gray that she'd been able to get her hands on, she would categorize her current feelings as ecstatic. For in her hands was the key to her wildest dream, to the heart of the man she loved with every fiber of her being.

The potion glistened within its vial, as if winking up at her as Juvia grinned down at it almost manically. It wasn't a love potion, of course. No, those had never ever worked out for the young woman, for the weather-based mage. She'd given up on love potions as a general rule after the last time one failed her... but that didn't mean Juvia was ready to give up on potions altogether!

The solution to her problems in bottle-form? It was just too enticing to resist. This time though... this time Juvia had gone a subtler route with things. This time, the potion she held in her hands wasn't anything as ham-fisted as bottled love. Instead, it was bottle suggestibility! Something to just... help the mood along a little, allowing two people who were enjoying one another's company to... take the next step.

Juvia can't help but giggle like a besotted maiden as she twists and turns a little atop her bed. Her imagination sparks as thoughts of her and Gray enjoying dinner, kissing, and... and going even further than that spring up in her mind. Holding the bottle close, Juvia bites her lower lip and whimpers in need. She can scarcely wait for tomorrow, when she'll put her plans into action.

Soon... soon, she and Gray Fullbuster will be together as they were always meant to be. Soon, she would be at his side and he would welcome her happily, and together they would... they would do all sorts of things, but good and naughty. Juvia's face heats up at the mere idea of what she and the handsome male mage could get up to. Even as one hand clutches around the bottle that holds the answer to all her problems, her other slides down her body, beneath her pajama bottoms, and into her panties.

Moans soon leave Juvia's lips, but she bites down on her pillow before they can get loud enough for anyone else to hear through Fairy Tail's paper-thin walls. And as she humps her hand and bites her pillow and clutches at her potion, the blue-haired mage knows deep down in her heart that this is the turning point. Everything is going to go right for her, from this moment on.

-x-X-x-

Everything had gone wrong. And Juvia, even though she hated to admit it, had royally fucked things up. It started when Mirajane asked her to deliver some groceries to Natsu. Apparently, the pink-haired man had just come back from a really tough mission, easily S-class, and he was in need of guild support. Well, Juvia considered Natsu a friend, and she WAS a member of Fairy Tail now. So, support him she would.

She really wanted to go to Gray right away, to be perfectly honest, but in the end, she just couldn't say no to Mirajane's hopeful eyes. So, she'd taken up the large bag of groceries in both arms and sought out the shack that Natsu and Happy called home. Of course, with her hands tied up with the bag of groceries, she'd ultimately had to stick the suggestibility potion in the bag, just to keep it safe and to minimize the chance of it falling out of her pocket or her hand. The groceries had been a little heavier than she expected but she'd gotten it done all the same.

Natsu's home had come into view quickly enough, and Juvia remembered thinking of how sweet and quaint the little domicile was. When she and Gray finally married, she'd love a little cottage like Natsu had, perhaps on the shore of a lake. Ooh, maybe Gray would build it for her! Wouldn't that just be so romantic!

That thought had only reinvigorated her drive to complete this favor for Mirajane and Natsu, so she could get a move on and get over to Gray's place. Unfortunately, that was... perhaps where her problems had started. Reaching Natsu's door, Juvia had knocked and waited patiently for someone to answer. What she got was a completely drained, utterly exhausted Natsu, and even Juvia was a little taken aback by the last of stamina from the usually boisterous male mage.

In the end, he'd greeted her with a yawn, she'd told him she was sent by Mirajane with groceries, and he'd taken the bag from her with a tired thank you. Then, he'd asked her if she wanted to come inside, but of course, Juvia had other plans. She'd said no, even mentioning to Natsu that she really needed to go see Gray.

Well used to her love for the other man, Natsu had simply shrugged and closed the door. Excited as all hell, Juvia had turned and began walking away. She'd gotten halfway down the road and hundreds of feet away, thinking about her life with Gray and how glorious it was going to be, before finally realizing she didn't have the potion on her anymore. Because she'd left it in the grocery bag Natsu had taken off her hands.

That was where she was now, marching back to Natsu's shack with wide eyes and a set jaw filled with determination. How could she have screwed up so badly?! Reaching Natsu's door, she knocks much more harshly than before, multiple times.

"Natsu! Natsu!"

The door comes ajar from the force of her smashing her fist into it, and Juvia takes the chance to burst into the small shack. Natsu is there of course... and so is the bag of groceries, which Juvia makes a beeline for, as soon as she lays eyes on them.

"Juvia? What the hell? What... what's going on?"

Natsu is standing right over the groceries when she reaches for them, but Juvia doesn't have TIME for him. She needs to get her potion and get to Gray! And there it is, her potion. Of course, Juvia doesn't notice the cap has come loose in all of the jostling, she doesn't see the crack between the potion's lid and the neck. She's too over-eager, reaching into the bag to grab what's hers, only for Natsu to grab her by the shoulder with some concern in his eyes.

This causes Juvia to trip forward, off balance as she already is in her haste. She yelps as, instead of closing around the neck of the potion bottle, her palm smacks into the thing, causing it to tip over and flip upside down in the bag of groceries.

"Juvia, what the hell is going on?!"

As she straightens herself up, the blue-haired girl looks over at Natsu's annoyed, befuddled expression. She can't help but feel a little guilty, now that the adrenaline is leaving her. Blushing at her impropriety, Juvia coughs delicately and looks away.

"A-Ah, apologies... I just... well, I had left something of mine in the bag of groceries, so I wouldn't drop them as I c-carried them, see. It's a bottle, and I'd like it back, please..."

Natsu rolls her eyes, clearly thinking she's ridiculous. He reaches into the bag of groceries for her, and a moment later extracts both her potion bottle and an apple. As he tosses the bottle over to her, he takes a bite out of the apple, clearly too famished and too hungry to be polite at this point in time. Juvia doesn't pay Natsu eating any mind though, in their line of work, you took what you could get.

Instead, she catches the bottle in both hands and holds it between her bosom with quite a lot of relief. She could still make her dreams come true, even with this little mishap. She could- Juvia's thoughts of her and Gray together forever grind to a halt when she realizes that the bottle is far lighter than it should be. Actually looking at it finally, Juvia despairs. Its empty. It's completely and entirely empty.

"You get what you need? Didn't you say you had to go see Gray or something?"

Juvia can't help it. She starts to break down right then and there, a broken sort of sob escaping her throat at seeing yet another chance with the love of her life going up in smoke. Outside, the weather quickly takes a turn for the worst, rain coming down in moments and thunder and lighting quickly following. Natsu looks at her with obvious confusion, not really knowing what's going on. He's already finished the first apple, and now he's moved onto some bread, which he chomps down on and swallows just as quickly, just as efficiently.

Still, Juvia IS one of his friends, and he wants to cheer her up somehow. Reaching into the bag of groceries again, Natsu comes out with another apple and some meat, offering the former to Juvia as he uses his magic to cook the latter with nothing but his barehand.

"Here, have an apple. They're extra juicy for some reason, maybe it'll cheer you up."

She recognizes that he's trying, in some far back corner of her brain. Perhaps that's why she takes the apple and nibbles at it. But she's not really paying attention, not to Natsu anyways. It's not like he would understand, not like he ever could understand. Honestly, what did he know about love? He'd always made light of her love for Gray, her absolute adoration.RêAd lateSt chapters at novelhall.com Only

But damn, this apple was really good, wasn't it? Juvia takes a larger bite, savoring it as she chews slowly before eventually swallowing. It was really, REALLY good. Almost... magically so. Juvia's eyes go wide as she realizes the reason why her potion was empty, and just where all of the contents of the bottle had to have gone. She whips around to warn Natsu, only to find she's far too late.

The bag of groceries is upended and empty at this point. Natsu, famished as he was, ate everything that Mirajane had her bring him in just a few short minutes. Then, it seems he passed out, ready to finally sleep off the exhausting mission he'd just completed, as well as the large amount of food he'd just consumed. Looking down upon his sleeping form, Juvia can't help but whine in frustration, moaning her disappointment out to the otherwise empty shack.

She was NEVER going to get Gray at this rate. Yet again, her purchases had failed her! Still, that meant her day had abruptly cleared up. She wasn't going to go to Gray without some sort of device to make him notice her, now was she! But for now, she could at least help Natsu. While the pink-haired man could easily sleep on the floor, and probably HAD slept in worse places, that didn't mean she should leave him there. It wasn't right.

Whatever confusion, doubts, or guilt Natsu had over all of this are blown away by that simple presentation. With Juvia giving herself up to him on a silver platter, all the young man can do is let out a roar of approval as he spears into the blue-haired mage from behind, filling her to the brim and exulting in her loud squeals. He grabs hold of her wide, gorgeous hips with both hands, and he fucks into her with all his might as she pushes back against him, moaning lewdly and loudly, begging him for more.

"I love you Natsu-Sama! I need you to love me back, love me as roughly as you can manage! All I want is your dick, all I want is your hard, muscular body taking me and making me your woman so savagely! Fuck me, Natsu! Fuck me, fuck me, FUCK MEEEEE!"

How can he do anything but? Natsu grunts and growls and fucks Juvia as hard as she can, much to her immense satisfaction. The two go at it for what feels like forever on Natsu's bed, even as the storm outside picks up with the intensity of Juvia's repeated orgasms. Eventually, she cries out as her eyes roll back in her head.

"P-Promise me, Natsu! Promise me that I can stay with you f-forever! Let me be yours, let me ALWAYS be yours!"

With a grunt, Natsu leans forward. He grabs a fistful of Juvia's hair, forcing her back to arch as he tilts her head up.

"I will... we'll always be together, Juvia."

Juvia's happiness is enough to fill the cottage with steam as he continues to fuck her so satisfyingly rough from behind. A few minutes later, and they both experienced an explosive orgasm, their minds and bodies and even souls feeling utterly in tune as they came with one another, Natsu's load spilling into Juvia's cunt and her pussy juices squirting down the length of his thick, throbbing prick.

What follows is more of the same. Neither of them is tired anymore, and even if they are, they won't let that stop them. Hours go by as Natsu and Juvia fuck all across Natsu's little shack, not just in the bed, but up against the walls, bent over the table, on top of the counter... everywhere. One such occasion has Natsu pinning Juvia down into a mating press, staring at her heart-shaped eyes in wonder, even as he pumps into her until he cums. She tells him she loves him, and then demands more.

Another time sees Natsu in a chair with Juvia on her knees before him, using her spectacular titties to give him a boobjob, her hands pressing her breasts along either side of Natsu's big fat dick as she moans and slides them up and down. Of course, he's far too big for just her breasts, so Juvia happily leans in to slurp at his cockhead whenever it comes up through her cleavage, her spit and saliva sliding down his length to make the passage through her tits all the slicker and more pleasurable.

Eventually, that becomes another blowjob entirely, Natsu's cock slipping free of her tits and sliding deeper past her lips. She stares adoringly into her eyes as she takes him into her mouth, while Natsu pushes more and more of his shaft into her throat while holding her head in place. He tells her what a good cock-sucker she is, speeding up Juvia's tongue action monstrously as he cums. Once she's swallowed it all, she looks up at him, smiles demurely, and asks quite gently for more.

Things continue in a similar vein as that. Fucking is all either of them want from one another right now. Getting plowed silly by Natsu is Juvia's greatest desire, and plowing her silly is Natsu's. Though, he does keep noticing the heart-shaped eyes, and as they fuck more and more, slowly but surely eroding their respective, monstrous libidos, Natsu finds himself more and more curious.

Its no wonder then, that some time later he finally asks. Juvia is atop him and slamming herself down on his cock again and again. Natsu groans as he takes hold of her hips and keeps her steady, his fingers squeezing into her sides as she holds onto the headboard behind Natsu for support, working her lower half up and down, side to side, gyrating and undulating her cunt across his shaft as her inner walls milk him for yet another release.

Staring into his eyes, Juvia goes in for a kiss, furiously making out with him as their tongues intertwine and Natsu returns the favor, kissing her right back. His hands slip from her hips to her spectacular ass then, squeezing and groping her perfectly shaped posterior as harshly as he can. The two of them cum one last time like that, together as they have countless times before. His seed erupts into her already stuffed womb yet again, and Juvia moans into Natsu's mouth as she orgasms from the delicious sensation of being filled by the man she loves.

Breaking the kiss, Juvia smiles down at Natsu with adoration and devotion clear in her heart-shaped eyes. Natsu smiles back, and that's when he finally asks the obvious.

"Hey, Juvia... why're your pupils heart-shaped? It's kind of weird, isn't it?"

Rather than answer him, Juvia just smiles and nibbles at her lower lip in a way that draws Natsu's gaze from her eyes to her mouth. Then, she grinds across his cock in just the right way and lets out a shuddering, breathy sigh.

"Please, Natsu-Sama... fuck me some more."

Shrugging, Natsu can't really deny that he wants to. So, he flips them over, landing Juvia on her back. Her hands go to the headboard again, this time back over her head as he begins to fuck her once more, thrusting into her with greater and greater speed as time goes on. She moans, she mewls, and she begs for his dick... because in the end, that's all Juvia wants now. It's all she'll ever want, ever again.

-x-X-x-

"Hm. I wonder what's going on with Juvia and Natsu. They turned in rather early, didn't they?"

It was a group mission, so of course all the usual suspects of Team Natsu plus one were together. With night having fallen, they'd stopped and set up a campsite, getting their tents up and huddling around a campfire. Well, all except for Juvia and Natsu. It had been Lucy who voiced her concern, the blonde furrowing her brow in confusion as she conveyed what she was thinking. The others around the campfire, Gray, Erza, and Happy, all react in differing ways.

Gray has a thoughtful frown on his face as he stares into the fire before him.

"I've got to wonder what Juvia is up to more than Natsu... she's been quite happy lately, hasn't she? If she's planning something, I'd really like to know what it is..."

Erza coughs delicately as she shrugs her shoulders.

"Maybe they just both caught a bug or something? Considering just how tired Natsu was after that one mission a little while back. I know Juvia was sent to give him some groceries. Maybe she got whatever he had and they're just still both recovering their strength."

Meanwhile, Happy snickers as his tail flicks back and forth behind him.

"Maybe they're off making out behind our backs!"

There's a pause... and then laughter all around the campfire. Not a single one of them actually believes that's possible, given Juvia's absurdly laser-focused love for Gray. Not even Happy really means it, as he continues to snicker at his own joke. Conversation around the campfire soon turns to other topics as each of them puts Natsu and Juvia's odd behavior out of their mind.

But in the end, Happy was closest to the truth. The missing pair weren't actually making out, but that was only because Juvia was biting down HARD on her bunched-up shirt as she rode Natsu's big fat cock in order to stifle her voice as it threatened to come out of her. Again, and again she bounced up and down on his dick, moaning into her shirt, her breasts exposed and bouncing and jiggling before Natsu's eyes.

His hands are on her ass, his smile is wide, and Juvia's is as well even as she holds her shirt bunched up between her teeth. Her gaze is filled with love and hearts, right up until her eyes roll back in her head fully the moment Natsu finally cums inside of her. Juvia has never been happier, even as she feels his seed painting her womb white. This is where she belongs, with Natsu, as his whatever. She doesn't need to even be his girlfriend or his wife, or his partner. So long as he'll take her as she is, so long as he'll fuck her senseless and bury his cock inside of her again and again, Juvia is happy.

Everything is as it should be.

-x-X-x-

If you'd like to read more of my work not seen on this website, check out and where I have over a thousand stories!

If you'd like to contribute to funding my writing at all, check me out on

Thanks for reading!

-x-X-x-

Looking for something Original from me to read? Check out !