Chapter 451

But

Qin Yi looked at Shen Lian, who was as proud as a peacock, and said to the judge, "your honor, article 148 of the criminal procedure law of our country stipulates that witnesses and appraisers should withdraw from court immediately after being questioned by both parties or by judges. Witnesses and expert witnesses shall not sit in on the trial of the case. There are also relevant provisions in civil litigation that witnesses are not allowed to sit in court; other witnesses are not allowed to be present when they are questioned. ——Shen Lian has been attending the trial, and her testimony can't be legal. "

Shen Lian's heart cluttered for a moment and said, "what I said is the truth. Why can't it be a legal testimony?"

Qin Yi said with a kind smile, "little sister, I have just given you the law popularization. If you don't understand it, you can go back to study first and testify when you understand it."

She turned her eyes to the defendant's lawyer. "The defendant's lawyer is also interesting. Such a big loophole didn't tell you. It can't be an undercover who can't see your big sister's behavior and eliminate harm for the people?"

The defendant's lawyer turned green.

Before he made such a mockery of Hu tingyue, Qin Yi turned back and hit him in the face. Suddenly, Qin Yi's vigilance increased several degrees.

In fact, it's not that he didn't tell Shen Yi, but that Shen Lian had the intention of committing a crime. In order to grasp the situation of the trial in time, he didn't tell the lawyer frankly.

Shen Lian's face was pale and her breath was short. Shen Yi worried: "is it OK to love you?"

Shen Lian managed to control her mood. She didn't help her. She also put her elder sister in a disadvantageous situation. She hated Qin Yi so much in her heart.

Under the agitation mood, the head began to feel dizzy.

"This lady is not feeling well. I'd better go to see a doctor first." Qin Yi light mouth, no longer admit that she is a witness.

Shen Lian stares at her, are you proud?!

Qin Yi returns with a faint smile.

With the permission of the judge, the bailiff immediately went to help her, but she refused to leave and insisted on returning to the auditorium.

"With regard to the last piece of evidence, I would like to ask witness Bao fan a few questions." The defendant's lawyer is aware that the second question of evidence needs to be communicated with the Shen family before deciding the defense plan. Now, he can only continue to refute other evidence. The current situation is really not conducive to Shen Yi, but single evidence can not be convicted, so there is no need to worry about it for the time being.

Bao fan has been waiting outside as a witness and is soon brought to court.

Bao fan was a thin young man with black glasses. Perhaps he had just lost his father. His face was pale, his lips were dry, and he was very haggard. Standing behind the witness stand, his eyes are always drooping, he is silent and looks very introverted.

The defendant's lawyer asked, "did your father Bao Guozhen contact you before he committed suicide by jumping off a building?"

"Yes." Bao fan's voice was hoarse but firm.

"How did he contact you?"

"Cell phones."

The lawyer's eyes flashed, "what did he say?"

Bao fan's lips moved and he said with difficulty: "he said that he had done something wrong. He shouldn't listen to Miss Shen. Now he can't go back. Let me take good care of my mother. If I can stay abroad in the future, I'd better not go back home."

These words are actually in the testimony submitted to the court. It is impossible for the defendant's lawyer not to know that he wants to confirm whether Bao fan has evidence in his hand that can clearly identify Shen Yi.

"Did he name Miss Shen?"

Bofan paused and said, "I'm sorry No

"That is to say, your father Bao Guozhen mentioned Miss Shen to you on the phone, but didn't say who was Miss Shen?"

"Yes."

"But as far as I know, your father didn't get through to you on the night of his jump. Where did you get in touch with your father and how did you hear what he said?" The defendant's lawyer grasped the key point and his eyes flashed.

Bao fan wiped his face, took a deep breath, and then managed to suppress his grief. "Yes, dad did call me before the accident. I was in class at that time, and I didn't answer the phone..."

No one thought that the call was a farewell.

He couldn't hear his father again.

Seeing his agitation, the defendant's lawyer said in a seductive tone: "if I understand correctly, you and your mother were brought back by Mr. Zhou Muze, right? During this period of time, you lived in an unknown place. I asked Mr. Zhou several times that I was refused to meet you. But you didn't get through to your father's phone. Why did you know what he said? Did someone ask you to say that? "

"No! The defendant's lawyer is making a confession! " Hu tingyue said.

The defendant's lawyer exclaimed, "witness, please explain why you didn't get through to your father's phone, but you heard him mention Miss Shen on the phone? Are you being bullied or seduced? Your mother didn't appear in court today. Did someone threaten you with perjury? "

The judge said, "witness, please answer the questions of the defendant's lawyer."

Bao fan raised his eyes and looked at the defendant's lawyer coldly, "who said I heard Dad talking on the phone?"

The defendant's lawyer had a bad feeling."Dad didn't get through to me and sent me wechat."

"It's impossible! He has no record on wechat! " The defendant's lawyer blurted out.

"Because Dad deleted it, but I still have it on my phone." Bao fan takes out his mobile phone from his pocket, opens wechat, turns the volume to the maximum, and plays Bao Guozhen's voice in court Fanfan, my father did something wrong. You should take good care of your mother in the future. Don't want to revenge. You can't afford that Miss Shen. After listening to her, dad has no way back now Don't come back if you can stay abroad. Dad just wants you to be OK. I'm sorry. Dad is sorry for you... "

It's not loud, but it's enough for people in court to hear.

Shen Yi frowns tightly, Bao Guozhen unexpectedly left such a handle, really hateful!

Bao fan's eyes turned red and glared at Shen Yi. Seeing that she had no fluctuation, her mood finally collapsed: "you forced my father to death! You are a murderer

"No!" The defendant's lawyer seized the witness's impropriety and immediately called into question: "the witness is obviously biased against my client, and his testimony is not reliable enough."

"This is the real evidence, not the witness." Hu tingyue cool road.

The defendant's lawyer had no choice but to adopt the formula of dragging words: "whether the pronunciation is true or not still needs to be identified. I want to verify the authenticity of the pronunciation."

The earlier Hu Ting expected that the other party would be like this, and took out a document from the file bag, "this is the identification result of authoritative experts from China's authoritative institutions. The voice in the mobile phone of the expert witness Bao fan is Bao Guozhen's own, without any traces of synthesis and forgery. Oh, if the defendant's lawyer still doesn't believe it, we can ask experts to make an appraisal in court. They are now out of court and can be summoned at any time. "