Chapter 453

Half an hour later, another session.

"Does the defendant's lawyer have any objection to the voice identification?" Hu tingyue asked first.

Of course, the defendant's lawyer would not be stupid enough to question the results of these experts, but he still had to leave the scene. "I need to ask the expert a few questions."

Experts have been waiting outside the court, summoned, and then walked into the court with the bailiff.

The defendant's lawyer asked them a few routine questions, as well as some professional questions about voice identification, asking them to explain why they could determine that the voice in Bao fan's wechat was Bao Guozhen.

The experts answered one by one.

The defendant's lawyer looked a little ugly, but did not deny the expert's appraisal results, and finally said: "I have no objection to Bao Guozhen's speech identification."

Hu Ting more low voice to Qin Yi way: "this guy is a bit wrong, I guess he held back bad moves."

Although the questions raised by the defendant's lawyer just now are very demanding and professional, Hu tingyue, as a senior lawyer and an old opponent's intuition, thinks that the defendant's lawyer is a little abnormal.

Qin Yi secretly nodded, "see what they have to do."

Sure enough, the defendant's lawyer said: "even if the voice in the wechat is Bao Guozhen's own voice, it can't show that Miss Shen He said is my client. According to the latest census, there are more than 6 million people with the surname of Shen in China, and there are more overseas Chinese and overseas Chinese. We can't assume that Miss Shen in Bao Guozhen's mouth is my client just because my client's surname is Shen. "

Hu tingyue said: "Bao Guozhen said that Miss Shen was so powerful that he couldn't even provoke him, the editor in chief of China's first-class media. This is in line with the identity of the defendant. If we contact other evidence, Miss Shen in Bao Guozhen's mouth is the defendant."

"This is a coincidence. Although the plaintiff denies the legality of Ms. Shen's testimony, we can extract evidence to prove that Ms. Shen's testimony is true. We can make a reasonable explanation for the evidence provided by you."

"Don't you think there are too many coincidences?" Hu Ting is more sarcastic.

"Coincidence does not mean guilt."

Shen Zhongfa no longer wanted to testify to Mr. Hu Guofei that he was not going to tell the judge that he was going to testify against the defendant

The defendant's lawyer and Shen Yi feel a little uneasy at the same time.

"I would like to ask directors Zhang and Li of sun weekly to testify in court."

Director Zhang and director Li soon stood on the witness stand.

Hu tingyue asked: "may I ask the two directors, after the publication of the false report, my client immediately released the interview recording, which led to the sun weekly being attacked and annihilated by public opinion. On the same day, the board of directors of sun weekly asked Bao Guozhen to withdraw the false report and apologize to my client. Is this true?"

"It's true."

"After the announcement of the recording, Bao Guozhen withdrew the false report, but refused to apologize." Director Zhang said.

Director Li nodded: "yes, I was very angry at that time. This kind of false report didn't conform to the original intention of sun weekly. Miss Qin Yi always had a good wind review. She didn't say anything wrong in the interview. Bad artists should be banned. But Bao Guozhen did something wrong and refused to apologize. We would like to send him to Miss Qin Yi to apologize."

Director Zhang touched director Li's arm. Flattery depends on the occasion.

Director Li coughed softly. "At that time, the whole board of directors was very dissatisfied with Bao Guozhen's behavior. You can ask him casually, and you all know it."

"The board of directors asked Bao Guozhen to apologize. Why didn't he apologize?" Hu tingyue asked.

"He took the position of editor in chief and his more than 20 years of working experience as a guarantee, and asked the board of directors to give him another day, and he firmly believed that the incident would turn over."

"Why is he so sure?"

"Specifically, he didn't say it, just implied that there was a very hard backstage behind this incident. However, before he jumped from the building, he once admitted to the emergency board that the reason why Miss Qin Yi's false report would be published was that a noble person supported him."

"Can you repeat what he said that night?"

Director Zhang thought, "at that time, the board of directors was discussing how to deal with a series of effects of false reports. Suddenly Bao Guozhen said," can you listen to me? " We all looked at him, and then he said, "I've been in this business for 20 years. Do you know what can and can't offend?"

Director Li nodded. "Yes, at that time, someone asked me what your dependence was. He didn't say it directly, but said," in a word, it's a noble person. "

"That's all?"

"That's it. All the people on the board of directors were there at that time and everyone knew."

"That is to say, Bao Guozhen published a false report to my client because he was instructed by a noble person to do so?"

"From what he meant, it was."

"That is to say, after my client published the interview recording, which led to a reversal of public opinion, he still refused to apologize because a noble person acted as the backstage for him, and he asked the board of directors to give him another day. Can I understand that he is determined that public opinion will reverse again within one day? What is going to happen in a dayDirector Zhang and director Li were shocked at the same time, but they did not. That night, there was a live broadcast of fans' self Immolation, and public opinion completely reversed. Qin Yi was reviled by thousands of people.

"I think so, because the self Immolation live broadcast happened that night, which is too coincident."

Hu tingyue nodded, "thank you for your testimony."

Then she looked at the defendant's lawyer in a sarcastic tone: "can the defendant's lawyer explain why Bao Guozhen and Miss Shen have never been in contact, but they have started to contact each other before the false report. Each contact happens to happen at a critical moment. Bao Guozhen is also instructed by a noble person like the accused to make a false report on my client, and he coincidentally affirms it Public opinion will certainly reverse. Zhang YingYing and Zhang Yingying accidentally contacted the defendant's IP address. Finally, Bao Guozhen coincidentally called the defendant before jumping off the building, and then coincidentally told his son that the person who instructed him was Miss Shen? "

The defendant's lawyer was speechless.

He would like to refute, but such obvious evidence is a coincidence. Can the judge believe it?

Seeing that he couldn't speak, Hu Ting turned her eyes to the judge: "your honor, the matter is very clear. Bao Guozhen was instructed by someone to make false reports on my client, and provoked the conflict between my client and y-name artist fans. Later, people behind the scenes used this contradiction to instigate Zhang Yingying to commit suicide and put the death responsibility of the three on my client The person behind the scenes is the defendant who has contacted Bao Guozhen several times and has the status of "noble person", Miss Shen Yi and Miss Shen Da! "

There was silence in the court.

The judge looked at the defendant and the defendant's lawyer, "can the defendant's lawyer have any objection to the inquiry of the plaintiff's lawyer?"

The defendant's lawyer was sweating, and Shen Yi's face was not good-looking.

The facts are obvious.

Just as the judge was about to speak, Shen Lian in the auditorium suddenly called out: "not big sister!"