My whole length was already inside Rachel's tight pussy and the moment Kaley pushed the tip of her rubber cock in as well, Rachel's whole body just tensed as she squeezed me even more. But yeah, Kaley was still letting Rachel get used to the additional phallic object pushing inside her nether regions but Kaley sent a loud and crisp slap on her tight ass that made Rachel let out a sharp gasp.
I could clearly feel how her insides tightened but Kaley started to play with her little ass while smothering a cheek with her free hand.
"Mmm... Your girl's so bad, you know?"
Kaley chuckled, "In a good way, right?"
"Pfft... Of course— Mmnh! Ah! Yes— D-Don't m-move yet, alright?"
Rachel was just squirming from the different sensations happening at once but as I joined in by simply caressing her back and kissing her neck, it didn't take long before Kaley tried her 2nd attempt.
"HnGH! W-Wait— N-Not yet... N–Not— Mmm... A-A bit more gentle—"
"Want me to pull out and feel Kaley for a bit?"
"S-Sure..."
"I'm not as big but— Here I go—"
"Mnn... Nn... Kaley... Oh, wow... P-Play with my ass..."
"We are," Kaley and I said at the same time.
"I-I mean... M-More..."
"Do you want us to just DP you instead?"
"W-Well... C-Can we try i-it on that one? Y-You know... P-Putting it in at the same time..."
"Sure!"
As Kaley reached in her pack for lube, Rachel just used her spit and her juices to get me inside her ass to prep her for two cocks, and the moment Kaley and I tried putting it in at the same time, it went it much easier and Rachel came from a few thrusts.
"Pfft! You two are the definition of a perfect couple, for real."
"Aww~ Thank you, Rachel! For the record, you're really nice too! Anyone would be lucky to have you—"
Then Rachel got suddenly quiet.
I nudged her, "Rachel?"
Kaley followed, "You okay? Is it something that I said—"
She let out a sigh before she got up and looked at us, "Alright... I-It's not what you said, Kaley, you're cool. But... There's another reason I can't stay over here... I-It's umm—"
Kaley cut in, "Hmm, is it Jennifer?"
"Wha— How'd you know?!"
I interjected, "We gotta tell you something too, she's psychic—"
"What?! For real?!"
"NO, I'm not! Not this again! I-I just saw your expression change a little earlier when Quinn— you know—"
"The big and muscley one, right?"
"Y-Yeah, your expression changed when she mentioned her name. And h-he did tell me that Jennifer's orientation is you know... A little complicated."
Rachel let out a soft sigh, "It's not complicated at all... We just love people, is all... It's just that... We're in a sort of a break right now— but we did agree to sleep around so... No harm, no foul on what we just did, and it's different from our little misunderstand earlier but... But—"
Kaley followed, "But you don't think it's helping?"
"Really! How did you know?!"
I added, "C-Can... Can you tell us the reason why? We might be able to help you two if you're both okay with it..."
"R-Really?"