Chapter 1327： arguing

La Niu Niu m is the fifth today, please recommend, please subscribe to the monthly ticket for one hundred and two plus

Is Jean-Baptiste Grenouille an Angel or a Devil? This has become the focus of the hottest debate after the premiere of "Perfume" that day, and this topic has also become the main theme of the definition of "Perfume" by major media. Not only is the audience wondering this, the media are also arguing about this At one point, this core proposition also basically affects the professional media and audience's perception of the film

British Sight & Sound took a positive view, arguing, "This film faithfully follows the original and presents an amazing world that is Evan Bell's best yet. work"

Among the comments, Sight & Sound said, "Jean-Baptiste-Grenoye, a child like a tick clinging only to a tree, life offers nothing but eternal hibernation To him, he tightly wraps himself in his inner world, quietly waiting for the last best moment And what he gives back to this world, there is nothing, not a smile, not a scream, not a single With bright eyes, even the slightest scent is unwilling to provide him, he is a being outside this world without taste, but with a natural sensitivity to scents, Jean-Baptiste Grenouille, From an ordinary person to an existence out of this world, but the other side of being a miracle existence is loneliness, so lonely that he can't feel his own existence and looks scared. Therefore, he returned to the top of the mountain and lived for seven years. Returning to the secular world again, he hopes to return from deification to humanization, from essence to nature. He hopes to prove that he is indeed real in this world.

Therefore, the audience can see the murder scene one by one, but they cannot feel the fear from the murder. They can only passively feel the gorgeous corpse scene with their own eyes. The pure limbs are beautifully twisted, and the church, stone The wall is a stark contrast between these environments, and it is worth watching quietly and quietly without making the audience think of anything bad. Murder is no longer an evil existence to satisfy personal desires. It is just that he strives to chase the end of an existence. Means, this pure to the extreme makes us unable to hate Jean-Baptiste Grenouille, makes us unable to hate those clear and pure eyes

When the film ends, Jean-Baptiste Grenouille stands on the execution stand, watching everyone surrender to their own desires. At that moment, he is sad. He can control the world through perfume, but Unable to prove his existence he is a being that has never been discovered, like a wisp of smoke, floating rootless in this world This despair brings him back to the place where he was born, leaving what is left to conquer the whole All the perfume of the world is poured on oneself and eaten by the hungry poor in the fish market One reincarnation, it's over

Evan Bell uses his gorgeous and exquisite lens to tell a thought-provoking story. He uses **** to describe heaven, dirty to describe purity, and horror to describe romance... This skill makes people have to be amazed.”

"Sight and Hearing" obviously loves "perfume" very much. They gave a perfect four-point evaluation, and gave the highest recognition to Evan Bell's work this time.

The same opinion was expressed by the British magazine Empire, "The light and shadows and silhouettes like Van Gogh's oil paintings fascinate people with the richness of the mess, the extreme poverty and the extreme luxury, in the endless color. People hold their breath and the shocking effect that perfume finally achieves is jaw-dropping, and the extreme of fictional art is brought into full play, which makes people amazed, sighed, hated, and delighted. In the scene of madness and insanity, all the essences of human nature that favor beauty, indulgence, drowning, and madness are in full bloom, so that the moment when people forget to denounce their sins and even indulge in them is the ultimate moment.”

Among the four-point evaluations of "Empire", it is believed that Jean-Baptiste-Grenoye's extremeness and purity make all sins take a back seat, and focus on the world built by this smell, at least in this world of smells, Jean-Baptiste Grenouille is an angel

Similar praise can also be seen in the famous German film professional magazine "Exhibition", which is the official media of the Berlin Film Festival every year.

"After I walked out of the movie theater, my consciousness was still filled with excitement and amazement. Everything, everything was so good, so good that no one else could match it, so good that it was desperate, so good it was scary.

History has always been accustomed to assigning tragic colors to legendary people, because from a certain point of view, their basic rights have been deprived by the mainstream society composed of so-called normal people and their ethics and morality. This world is obviously not tolerant enough to be tolerated. Accept those minorities who are incompatible with public cognition and ethics, because it is impossible to have a set of morals that can find every group in society, and it is impossible to have a set of policies that can satisfy both those in power who advocate control and the people who pursue freedom. For example, homosexuality; for example, Jean-Baptiste Grenouille

'She is lonelier than the fireworks', 'Peerless Enchantress', 'Sea Pianist', 'Edward Scissorhands', 'Artificial Intelligence', 'Brokeback Mountain', 'Across America'... They are all chasing wildly Their own dreams, persistence, arrogance, publicity, presumptuous, unrestrained, and freedom, in mainstream society, they are not recognized existences, but in their world, they are unique existences, enough to make everyone The existence of people who are amazed may be that they declare their existence in a different way, but in this society occupied by the so-called mainstream ideas and moral concepts, they can never find their traces, so there is only a trace of existence. No traces can be found now, but also add 'perfume'

Watching Grenouille ignorantly exploring the world with scent, dazedly searching for ways to preserve scent, and then escaping from this world repressed by scent Loss and innate sensitivity to smells formed the cruelest opposition in the world. He was a being who was never compatible with this world, so he began to chase his own existence in an extremely gorgeous and cruel way, but In the end he failed and he returned to the place where he was born, the stinking, filthy place, where he was bathed in a perfume that was unique in this time, and then kissed wildly in the raw **** of the crowd, Shredded, dismembered, and devoured the next day, the sun still rose, and the world still revolved as usual

Grenouille's life is a journey, a journey to end loneliness and pain forever, a journey to try to return the soul, a journey to defy the rules of human society, and a journey to experience the highest value of life. The life that disappeared under his hands was not only a journey. Is it life, the established rules in this world, or the prevailing thoughts and morals in this society, which bind the entire human mind, and put Grenouille on the opposite side of the world, just like his lack of smell, no one Will care about his existence, but this **** is too fragile for Grenouille. He uses his persistence and simplicity to gorgeously crush everything into pieces. Indeed, those disappearing lives represent sin. , but Grenouille, who did not belong to this world at first, is trying to find his own existence in these disappearing lives. Sadly, he can never be found.

He is an angel who does not belong to this world. He blooms his life in the most splendid and splendid way, infinitely splendid because of loneliness, infinitely pure because of perseverance, infinitely brilliant because of short-lived life, just like the fireworks that bloom in that moment. , in the dark night sky unscrupulously released all the gorgeousness, and then across the sky, disappeared without a trace

I pray that in the vast and fertile soil of history and literature, such a strange, free, and grotesque soul can be left with a small piece of soil that belongs to it, so that it can ignore laws and ethics and fly freely."

The commentary of "Show Screening" is picturesque, which makes people re-examine the film with a poetic eye like a movie. On the opposite side of these media, there is also a group of roaring and roaring media. The power of this group of media is no less than that of admirers. vocabulary, which pushes the film "Perfume" to the moral gallows, condemning the work's depravity, thus avoiding moral depravity

"Premier" also appeared at the Cannes Film Festival this time. Among the three major European film festivals, Cannes is the most Hollywood-friendly film festival. The American media also has the most presence in Cannes except Toronto. It was expected that this time, Elliott Carter could finally express his dissatisfaction with Evan Bell, not only because of his many allies, but also because of "perfume" The film gave him enough opportunities

"The Fall of Morality", which became the title of Elliott Carter's film review, coupled with a zero-point evaluation, such a heavy review and rating can clearly see the "premier"'s impact on the film "Perfume". It's not just accusation, it's serious criticism

"When I watched 'Perfume', I already felt the anger of renunciation. Evan Bell borrowed the double-edged sword of literature and art to obliterate the truth so bluntly, and praised sin so bluntly. The bottom line of morality has already been reached. If a literary and artistic work does not have a position of truth, and some are only vague views of right and wrong, it is equivalent to a person without a soul.

It is undeniable that the world under Evan Bell's lens is extremely beautiful, with delicate narration, beautiful pictures, beautiful soundtrack, and actor-level performance. The arrogance of the film is placed in the highest position. It worships the sins of human beings. It does not find the real beauty. It is a loss in itself. The worst thing is that this loss will also have an inestimable impact on the audience. Reflection, will go to a terrible extreme

This seems to have become a convention in so-called literary works or philosophical works, blurring the line between angels and demons, so as to interpret the moment of execution in the final square of existential films, the bishop shouted angels to a serial killer, and everyone To succumb to one's own desires, it is as if the whole world is convinced by Grenouille's innate charm, and then it is reflected in the most primitive and limitless instinct, which is a complete abandonment of the moral bottom line. The film borrows Grenouille's talent for smell and downplays the sin he has committed by attributing what he did to the purest pursuit, but the problem is that in the real world, if everyone succumbed to If you pursue your own desires and desires purely, then the whole society will be occupied by sins and desires

In my eyes, Grenouille is just a transgender who grew up in a loveless environment. His personality is split. He plunders the lives of others to satisfy his own ideals. Except for extreme self-centeredness, I can't find him. any positive words

I hate those who do evil in the name of faith. I hate those who destroy the moral bottom line in the skin of civilization and art. I hate those who use the so-called philosophical dialectics to mislead the world. Perfume, a wonderful proposition, countless flowers It is crushed and extracted, and finally gets a drop of fragrance that has been handed down to the world. But what we need is the praise of the devotion of flowers, not the praise of the devil who crushed the flowers"

Eliot Carter used almost all the words and sentences to express his disgust for the film "Perfume", and he even sent "Perfume" to the guillotine with a "zero" rating. At one point, standing behind Elliott Carter was a very large number of supporters, much more than the original "Brokeback Mountain"

Strictly speaking, after the release of "Perfume", mixed reviews were the best reviews, with 50 percent saying the film was excellent, and 50 percent saying Evan Bell made a demon beautifully Packaging is heinous. Therefore, the supporters headed by "Sight and Hearing" and the opposition headed by "Premier" almost launched a bayonet fight, making the film "Perfume" fall from its premiere. in the endless debate

Outburst asking for double monthly tickets, asking for annual works tickets, asking for subscriptions and unfinished to be continued later) rq

[Registered members can get a private bookshelfconvenient]

1327 Controversy of Great Artists